April 14, 2008 - 8:17 pm

Is this art?

Dori writes...

a-dog1 a-dog2

a-dog3 a-dog4

PI art critic Regina Hackett's blog tipped me off to this story. A Costa Rican artist - Guilermo Vargas Habacuc - has generated international outrage with this work of "art".

He took a starving dog off the streets of San Jose, Costa Rica and tied it up in an art gallery. Food was placed where the dog could smell it - but the poor creature could not reach the food. The dog starving to death was Habacuc's work of art.

You want an example of the slippery slope of an art world where anything goes? This is just an extension of the moral depravity of artists like Robert Mapplethorpe with his bullwhip in the anus... of Andrew Serrano with "Piss Christ"... when you have acceptance of works like those, it is not a tremendous moral leap to starving a dog. It's all a matter of degree.

The artist in this case says he wanted to generate conversation about the plight of thousands of dogs that are roaming the streets, starving to death every day in his city. He has indeed generated conversation.



  • Add A Comment

  • Dark Jedi wrote...
    This is animal cruelty
    There is no reason for this guy to torture an animal and starve it. He needs to be fined, and arrested for animal cruelty. THIS IS NOT ART! IT'S SICK!!! If he wanted to show the plight of dogs, there are plenty of mediums to do that. Photography, sculpture, maybe even video (although animals still suffer in video). Better watch our government Dori. King county and/or Seattle may want a similar art exhibt at a water reservoir or fish ladder.
  • gmckie wrote...
    aRt?
    Why don't someone chain up Guilermo Vargas Habacuc just out of reach of food and we call it aRt? http://gregory-mckie.com
  • GlassBoxShoes wrote...
    Lame
    How does this represent a starving dog roaming the street? It's tied to the wall. Shouldn't it get to roam around the gallery? I bet he would attack that [no swearing please] artist and eat him.
  • Johan In Burien wrote...
    Same as Michael Vick's "Sport"
    Regina Hackett calling this "art" is no more reflective of people who enjoy "art" than Michael Vick's abuse of dogs is reflective of people who enjoy "sports". Vick called what he did a sport and wound up in jail. This guy needs to sit right next to him in the same prison cell. This is also another example of why I have long ago rejected the idea of the "slippery slope". Reasonable lines can always be drawn by reasonable people. When I see or hear someone (like Dori!) invoke the "slipper slope" argument this is my translation: "I'm out of real arguments that make sense but I'm too pig headed to admit I'm wrong". Think about it, Dori, everyone uses the slippery slope when they are losing the fight and just don't want to give it up.
  • DarcieAZGirl wrote...
    An artistic "bone" in his body?
    I thought artists were supposed to be the starving ones. With filth like this, it's not surprising. Where do guys like this even earn their artistic credentials? What's next? Academy Awards for Snuff Films?
  • Grace wrote...
    Sorry buz/off
    The previous comment was mine. Attention web devs... :)
  • OriginalCin wrote...
    Well, this is basically what I was gonna say. Darn it.
    Edward Winkleman's blog (admittedly against posting in reference to the whole thing in the first place) states pretty much what I was gonna post on this earlier, but I wanted to read everything on it, first. "There is no hypocrisy revealed here. A dog tied in a gallery and not fed will die. A stray dog left to its own devices in the streets at least has a fighting chance to survive, reproduce, and/or even enjoy moments of its life to some degree. The piece is weak because the premise is maudlin and false." It's kinda like a fake pregnancy to relate to being pregnant. Intentionally starving a dog to relate to starving dogs. Society has become so numb to the natural occurances that it takes some stirring up to really awe people into action. See "Shock Art" post above. A point could have just as easily been made with truly artistic effort put into documenting and capturing evidence of the natural occurance. See Dark Jedi's post above, too.
  • Kate wrote...
    Is the King Co. Council aware of this?
    You've got to be kidding me? Art? No way! Animal abuse - absolutely! This is an extremely sad commentary to the mentality of so many in the world today - where is their conscience?? Not to make light of this, but have you notified the Metro King Co. Council? In light of their recent expenditure of paying $85,000 for a so-called "consultant" to examine, then rip apart the caring officers and volunteers in the Animal Control Services Dept., maybe they want to send him to Costa Rica. This type of thing makes me ill.
  • Ken Kion wrote...
    Dog Art
    In order to get the message across about starving dogs in Costa Rico, did he actually have to let the dog die! The pictures alone are horrifing enough. His time should be used to round up all of these dogs, feed them and find homes or put them down humanly. I would be assamed to call myself an "artist". He's right up there with Hitler and his boys, maybe he's a grandson of one of them!








News
Local
National
World
Money
Lifestyle
Sci/Tech
Odd News
Politics

Multimedia
Photo Galleries
Videos
Sports
Mariners
Seahawks
Sounders
College
Storm
Blogs
NBA
Golf
NHL
Tennis
Olympics
Auto Racing
Entertainment
Dining
Movies
Movie Times
Calendar of Events
Entertainment News
Television
Travel
Tom Douglas
Chef Jeremy
Tom Tangney
Fit in the City
Seattle Fashionistas
the mixtape
Weather
Local Conditions
School Closings
Earthquake Tracker

Traffic
Current Conditions

Podcasts
Download past shows
Daily audio roll
Blogs
Dave Ross
Dori Monson
Ron and Don
TBTL
David Boze
Michael Medved
Frank Shiers
Phil the News Junkie
MyNorthwest Blog
Shannon Drayer
Kevin Calabro
Brock and Salk
97.3 KIRO FM
Shows/Hosts
Schedule
Events/Contests
Press Releases
Community Outreach

770 KTTH: The Truth
Shows/Hosts
Schedule

710 ESPN Seattle
Shows/Hosts
Schedule
Home   |   Contact Us   |   Terms of Use   |   Privacy Statement   |   Copyright Infringement   |   Employment   |   EEO Public File Report   |   Contest Rules   |   Set Us as Your Home Page   |   RSS
Copyright © 2010 Bonneville International. All rights reserved.