powered by Bonneville Seattle - News Talk 97.3 KIRO FM and 770 KTTH: The Truth

Updated Dec 12, 2008 - 8:19 am

Atheist holiday sign returned

Comments   |   Print this   |   E-mail this   |  
An anti-religion placard posted alongside Christmas displays drew a thief, a preacher, a part-time elf and a security detail to the state Capitol on Friday, as a weeklong uproar over religious speech hit a bizarre peak.

It all started Monday, when the Wisconsin-based Freedom From Religion Foundation unveiled a winter solstice sign in the grand marble hallways around the Capitol Rotunda.

The sign's atheistic message - reading in part that "religion is but myth and superstition" - drew top billing on conservative commentator Bill O'Reilly's TV show.

Several days of angry messages to Democratic Gov. Chris Gregoire followed, and on Friday morning, someone removed the atheists' sign and apparently hustled it out of the Capitol.

A radio station in Seattle, about 60 miles north, soon reported that an unidentified man had dropped off the pilfered placard, and the Washington State Patrol dispatched someone to pick it up.

Meanwhile, people flocked to the Capitol to check out the crime scene, set up their own protest signs and speak to a bank of TV news cameras jamming the hallway.

Among the crowd was James Pritchard of Seattle, who wore a pointy green hat and passed out candy-striped business cards proclaiming him "J. Elfus, Special Assistant to the Claus."

Despite his obvious preference for Christmas, Pritchard said he wants everyone to celebrate any holiday they like. But he was offended by the atheists' message, which he felt was designed mostly to mock religion.

"I heard about what was going on down here, and we had to order a truckload of coal," he said.

And that was just the start.

Pastor Ken Hutcherson, a Christian preacher well-known here for his commentary on social issues, also arrived to put up a sign that flipped the atheists' message into an affirmation of religion. Another small group put up a handmade poster reading, "The fool hath said in his heart, 'There is no God.'"

Several other parties submitted applications to state groundskeepers, seeking to display everything from a set of Nativity balloons to an aluminum Festivus pole - an homage to the invented "holiday for the rest of us" coined by the long-running comedy show "Seinfeld."

Burly State Patrol troopers paced the hallway the whole time, presumably guarding against any other shenanigans. Statues of the Holy Family remained undisturbed in their cedar stable.

Annie Laurie Gaylor of Madison, Wis., a co-president of the Freedom From Religion Foundation, said the group planned to install a replacement solstice poster until the proper sign could be recovered.

The group has displayed a similar sign in the Wisconsin Capitol for more than a decade, and has gotten used to this sort of response. For the first few years, opponents of the anti-religious message have turned the sign to face the wall, stolen it, and even showered it with acid, she said.

"It is interesting that our views are so threatening that they have to be stolen and stifled completely," Gaylor said.

Gregoire and Republican Attorney General Rob McKenna have defended the atheists' right to display their sign in the Capitol.

The state began granting broader access to religious displays a few years back, after a Jewish group added a Hanukkah menorah to the long-standing display of a massive evergreen Christmas tree - these days called a "holiday tree" - sponsored by the Association of Washington Business.

A local real estate agent sued after his subsequent request for a Nativity scene was denied, but the case was settled and the creche installed. This year is the first time the Freedom From Religion Foundation added its holiday message to the mix.

State carpenter Jim Buenzli, who first noticed the missing atheist sign Friday morning, said he was fed up by the whole furor. That's why he applied for permission to place the Festivus pole, which he planned to purchase and install next week.

"I got sick of the way these things were going, so I wanted to put some humor into it," Buenzli said. "They're making a big mockery out of our state on the news."

---

AP Writers Doug Esser, Manuel Valdes and Rachel La Corte contributed to this report.

© 2008 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Comments (20)
  • Add A Comment

  • Captain America wrote...
    We still don't know wo took it.
    I suggest that an Atheist might well have grabbed the thing and taken it to a County Music station on purpose to raise the specter of "religious intolerance"... I'd be curious to know who was responsible. If it was a person of faith, they were foolish.
  • spearharper wrote...
    Don't you know it !
    Totally agree, note her response ....""It is interesting that our views are so threatening that they have to be stolen and stifled completely," Gaylor said. " yet they are the ones that but up a mean and hateful sign ....
  • Canuckophile wrote...
    KMPS
    They dropped it off for Ichabod and KMPS radio. They seemed to be having a heyday with it. I'm sure Antioch Bible is happy for their press on the matter too. *barf*
  • JDoSeaWA wrote...
    Paganism and Winter Solstice celebration is "religion".
    Dan Barker is a hypocrite and clearly hostile to opposing religions. He taints the very notion of Atheism by taking a position of insisting integration of ideals into the argument - which means that he has taken a religious argument. Pagan rituals are "religion". Winter Solstice celebrations are "religion". Establishing resistance and demanding laws of separation is a clear violation of the 1st Amendment, for discriminating against the voice of religion in the public arena in the market of ideas is "make laws that prohibit". I believe it's entirely within the capabilities of the Atheist, rather the Paganist Dan Barkers ability, to create a perspective that a "christian" would have stole the sign. That's interesting, considering that a real christian would not do so, for if they follow the scriptural teachings, then they are to simply "turn the other cheek" or "be glad when they persecute you in my name". But, I guess that's just my opinion. Thought I believe the facts speak for themselves. The "Freedom against Religion" foundation is a religious organization, and the name is clearly one of anti-constitutional intents.
  • donjr wrote...
    Charter For Compassion
    I suggest that everyone settle down, take a breath or two, and then point your browser to http://charterforcompassion.com. It's time we all grew up and remembered the golden rule. We can all get together on this!
  • Captain America wrote...
    DonJr: Take a deep breath?
    You seem troubled that we are taking issue with the folks who put the sign up. Are you surprised that people of faith would be offended when someone put up a sign about one of the major facets of our lives that reads in part "religion is but myth and superstition"? I am willing to be tolerant, and inclusive. I will not, however, sit quitely while somone intentionally gives offense. The vast majority of Americans profess faith and keep it to themselves. Why should someone intentionally offer offense to us? Have these folks never been told to let sleeping dogs lie? If you poke a sleeping dog you might get bit.
  • bud in oly wrote...
    The important thing is
    that the sign was found...thank God!
  • Captain America wrote...
    Bud, you make me laugh! Thanks.
  • Korry wrote...
    Christian arrogance makes me laugh
    The popularity of the Christmas season really doesn't have much to do with religion. It's the retail holiday season. It's retailers that have made Christmas what it is in the United States. And FDR accomodated them by moving Thanksgiving to closer proximity, to extend the shopping season. The founders of this country didn't even celebrate Christmas. A nativity scene certainly is a religious representation. And it has no business being on public property, unless ALL such representations are welcome. The Christian-centric attitudes that find this offensive are nauseating, as usual, this time of the year. As long as Christians insist on shoving their version of "the reason for the season" down the public's collective throats, expect it to be challenged.
  • Korry wrote...
    Another thing that makes me laugh
    Is the persecution complex so many Christians demonstrate. We live in what, by design, was intended to be a secular nation, yet is ridiculously Christian-centric. And Christians are so threatened by that, that if anyone openly challenges their beliefs by publicly stating personal beliefs that differ from theirs, they behave as if they're about to be fed to the lions. Y'all really need to stop playing victim. It's pathetic.


More headlines...





Home   |   Contact Us   |   Terms of Use   |   Privacy Statement   |   Copyright Infringement   |   Employment   |   EEO Public File Report   |   Contest Rules   |   Set Us as Your Home Page   |   RSS
Copyright © 2009 Bonneville International. All rights reserved.